Does the name Baptist matter? Or is it merely a label that can be retained or discarded without losing anything of significance?

This is not a new question. When I began pastoral ministry in 1980, the church growth movement was gaining momentum, with an increasing emphasis on making churches more appealing to the unchurched. Some pastors began removing the name Baptist from their churches, believing that a less distinctive identity would attract more people. Today, that thinking continues, as churches drop the Baptist name in hopes of removing perceived barriers to reaching their communities.

I would like to present a different perspective.

I am not merely Baptistic in my beliefs. I gladly identify both myself and the church I pastor by the name Baptist. To me, that name represents biblical convictions worth holding, a spiritual heritage worth honoring, and an identity worth maintaining.

In other words, I believe the name is integral, not merely incidental. Here are three reasons why:

1. To Emphasize Biblical Doctrine 

Doctrine matters. What a church believes determines what it teaches, how it worships, and how it carries out its mission. The name Baptist identifies a body of biblical convictions that we believe are important enough to teach, practice, and preserve.

From the beginning, doctrine has been central to the life of the local church. Acts 2:42 tells us that the first church “continued stedfastly in the apostles’ doctrine and fellowship.” Doctrine was the foundation of their fellowship. It is the glue that binds a church together. We are united not merely by shared activities or relationships, but by a common commitment to the truth of God’s Word.

As a Baptist church, we share specific doctrinal convictions concerning the authority of Scripture, salvation, baptism, the local church, and Christian living. These are often summarized in eight “Baptist distinctives,” which we teach using the acrostic BAPTISTS:

  • Biblical authority in all matters of faith and practice: We believe the Bible is inspired and infallible and is the final authority. It is from God’s Word that we understand and teach the fundamental doctrines of our faith as well as pattern our church polity. (See 2 Timothy 3:16; John 17:17; Acts 17:11; Hebrews 4:12; 2 Peter 1:20–21.)
  • Autonomy or self governing power of the local church: We believe that every local church should be independent of a hierarchical framework or outside governmental structure. (See Colossians 1:18; Acts 13–14, 20:19–30; Ephesians 1:22–23.)
  • Priesthood of believers: God’s Word assures believers that we have direct access to God through our relationship with Christ. We believe and teach that the priesthood of the believer is the unspeakably precious privilege of every child of God. (See Hebrews 4:14–16; 1 Timothy 2:5–6; 1 Peter 2:5–10.)
  • Two offices within the church: The New Testament establishes two offices within the local church—pastor (also called elder or bishop) and deacon. Scripture teaches that these offices are to be filled by qualified men of godly character (Philippians 1:1; 1 Timothy 3:1–13; Titus 1:5–9). Pastors are responsible to shepherd and lead the congregation through God’s Word, while deacons serve the practical needs of the church. Biblically and historically, Baptists have held a complementarian position concerning the roles of men and women in the church. Today, however, some churches are departing from this biblical pattern, embracing egalitarian views of church leadership and appointing women as pastors. Others practice a form of soft complementarianism, permitting women to teach the Word to the assembled congregation or establishing deaconess boards that function as church officers. We believe Scripture clearly establishes the pattern for these roles (1 Timothy 2:12).
  • Individual soul liberty: We believe that each person must make a personal decision of repentance and faith in Christ. (See Romans 10:9–17, 14:1–23.) Parents do not make this decision for their children, and the government cannot make it for its people. Additionally, each person is responsible before God in matters of holiness and conscience.
  • Separation of church and state: The state should have no power to intervene in the free expression of religious liberty. (See Matthew 22:21; Acts 5:29–31; Romans 13:1–4.)
  • Two ordinances—baptism and the Lord’s Table: These ordinances have no part in salvation and only serve as pictures of what Christ did for us. (See Matthew 28:19; 1 Corinthians 11:23–26; Acts 2:38–43, 8:36–38; Romans 6:1–6)
  • Separation and personal holiness: We believe that Christ’s ultimate sacrifice demands our complete consecration, and we desire that our daily living would reflect the holiness of our great God. (See 2 Corinthians 6:14; 1 Peter 1:16.)

These eight distinctives do not encompass everything we believe. Foundational doctrines such as the Trinity and the deity of Jesus Christ are not included in this acrostic. Nor are these convictions held exclusively by Baptists; other churches share some of them. But taken together, they identify a distinctive set of biblical beliefs concerning the nature and practice of the local church.

We do not hold these convictions because they are Baptist. We are Baptists because we believe these convictions are biblical.

2. To Honor Our Spiritual Heritage 

The name Baptist carries a heritage that is longer and larger than my generation or this moment in history. I am the beneficiary of generations of believers who stood for the truths I preach today, many at the cost of their freedom or their lives.

Doctrinally, we trace our heritage back to the New Testament itself. In the earliest churches established by the apostles, the pattern of biblical Christianity was clear. The Scriptures were the authority for faith and practice, salvation was received through personal faith in Jesus Christ, and local churches were composed of believers who had followed the Lord in baptism.

Throughout the centuries that followed, there were believers and churches who sought to remain faithful to these truths, even as established state churches emerged and began persecuting those who refused to conform to doctrines and practices that were contrary to Scripture.

We know less than we would like about these groups. Some of their names have survived in history; many others, no doubt, were erased through persecution. Their record is in Heaven.

Not every group who resisted the Roman Catholic Church’s encroachments held to all the Baptist distinctives. But I am grateful for those who made Scripture, rather than the state, their authority for faith and practice.

Among those groups were the Waldensians, who emerged in the twelfth century and emphasized the authority of Scripture and the preaching of God’s Word. I have visited the caves in the Piedmont valleys of northern Italy where Waldensian believers gathered during times of persecution. It is a sobering experience to stand in those places and consider the faith and courage of those who worshipped there.

During the Protestant Reformation, Anabaptists took a courageous stand for the authority of Scripture, believers’ baptism, and the biblical local church. Although the Protestant Reformers rejected important errors of the Roman Catholic Church, many retained the union of church and state, and some even persecuted Anabaptists.

For their biblical convictions, Anabaptists were hunted, imprisoned, tortured, and killed. Felix Manz, an early Anabaptist leader, was drowned in the Limmat River in ZĂĽrich, Switzerland, on January 5, 1527, because he refused to abandon his belief in baptism following personal faith in Christ. I have stood beside that river and reflected on what his sacrifice means to those of us who freely practice believers’ baptism today.

In the centuries that followed, Baptists carried these New Testament convictions from England to America. From Thomas Helwys in England to Roger Williams in Rhode Island, they stood for biblical truth and religious liberty, often at great personal cost.

Even in colonial America, persecution of Baptists continued. In 1651, Obadiah Holmes was publicly whipped in Boston for his Baptist convictions. He could have avoided persecution by conforming to the established church, but he refused to surrender the biblical convictions he held.

Despite opposition, Baptists continued to proclaim the gospel and defend the principle that the state has no authority over the conscience of man. Their persistent advocacy helped lay the groundwork for religious liberty to be protected in American law, including the First Amendment to the Constitution.

By the late 1700s, Baptists were helping launch the modern missionary movement. William Carey carried the gospel from England to India, while Adoniram and Ann Judson later took it from America to Burma. Their sacrifice and missionary zeal inspired generations of missionaries who followed.

What a rich spiritual heritage we have inherited! These were men and women who valued biblical truth more than their own comfort, freedom, or even their lives. Why would I want to distance myself from such a heritage? I count it a privilege to identify with those who have stood for Christ and for the biblical convictions I hold. 

3. To Give a Clear Identity 

There is an honesty factor in using the name Baptist as well. I want people, both saved and unsaved, to know what we believe.

For Christians seeking a church home, a church’s name can provide a helpful indication of what they will find when they attend. It is a starting point for understanding the church’s doctrinal convictions and practices.

For those who do not know Christ, the name Baptist distinguishes our church from other churches they may be familiar with. People sometimes ask me what the difference is, for instance, between a Baptist and a Catholic church. That’s an opportunity to explain what we believe about salvation and share the gospel.

Do some people have a negative association with Baptists and choose not to attend our church? Possibly. But the same could be said of those who have negative associations with Christianity or churches in general. Removing the name may eliminate one question, but it also removes an opportunity to explain what we believe and why. 

A clear identity is important within our church family as well. As I write, this past Sunday we had a Starting Point class with many who have recently been saved through the outreach ministry of Lancaster Baptist Church members. In that class, we explained what we believe using the BAPTISTS acrostic. We also shared some of the history behind the name, including the testimony of believers who gave their lives for these convictions. 

These new Christians will also be encouraged to participate in our Continue discipleship program, which covers the Baptist distinctives in a lesson on the local church. 

We want our members to know that Lancaster Baptist Church is a Baptist church by conviction. These are not simply beliefs held by the pastor or printed in a doctrinal statement. They are truths we teach, practice, and embrace together as a church family.

Identify Openly 

If you pastor a Baptist church, I encourage you to gladly identify it as such. Put the name Baptist on your sign, your website, and your literature. Don’t leave people guessing about what your church believes.

But more importantly, make sure the convictions behind the name are taught from your pulpit and practiced in your congregation. A name alone cannot preserve biblical truth. That requires a deliberate commitment to God’s Word.

Hold fast to biblical doctrine. Thank God for our spiritual heritage. And gladly embrace the identity of a Baptist church.

After all, if we believe these truths are worth living by, they are certainly worth being known for.

Pin It on Pinterest